Review – The Windmill – Mindscapes – by John Wenlock-Smith

If, like me, you enjoy symphonic prog, then you will find much to enjoy in this shorter album from Norway’s The Windmill. With definite touches and traces of Wish You Were Here in the long first track Fear, ‘Mindscapes’ has as good an opening segment as I’ve heard on many an album. This release also contains three shorter tracks, all of which show a different facet of the band

The vocalist Erik Borgen has a wonderful, if somewhat unusual voice, it reminds me in places of Roine Stolt of The Flower Kings. Also memorable here is the saxophone of Morton L. Clason which adds something of great depth to all the keyboards and clout of the rest of the band. Fear has a great soundscape and some dynamic passages, along with a great organ solo. It’s also, despite being nearly twenty-three minutes in length, a very endearing track with lots happening during its duration. In fact, the more I’ve heard it the better it gets for me, as it reveals deeper, hidden complexities which, when all taken together, forms a most impressive piece. The song  is in three distinct sections, Fear, Back Against The Wall and Amnesia, the middle section has a great urgency and wonderful interplay between the flute and the rest of the band, it also benefits from a strong chorus and refrain.

I really like this track, it has grown on me considerably as I have become more familiar with it. A good guitar break helps move the track along before an extended keyboard solo is introduced to the proceedings. Thereafter a flute solo plays as the songs moves into its second section and this is a well orchestrated part with good keyboards and more flute stylings, all of which add to the overall feel and impression the track is seeking to create. And create it well it does too, as this song really does make a favourable impression and impact.

Calton Hill is a tribute to the band’s good friend Brian McNeil who was based in, or certainly very well acquainted with, the city of Edinburgh. The song is about walking around the city and the delights of Calton Hill which offers a good view of the city and is adorned with monuments and is a very pleasant area to explore. I know, I did it over 30 years ago and long to revisit once again. The shorter  and more delicate sounding I Still Care seems to be about a loved one who is not around any more but, even so, he still cares about her. It’s a wistful rather than cloying song, it is very tender and heartfelt though. The final track Nothing In Return is a bit of a different beast though, as it has a heavier sound with a degree of crunching guitar, almost like Grunge Prog! The presence of the flute is clearly heard and felt and this actually really works with this song because the contrast with the guitar is distinct and the flute brings a degree of lightness to proceedings. A wild synth solo is played with increasing urgency and power which makes an definite impact. The track then heads out in a romping/rollicking section, all synths and guitar riffs in tandem and unison. The impressively solid bass of Arnfinn Isaksen is felt here and his weight adds much to the dynamics at play here. This song may be brief but it is certainly powerful and impactful.

‘Mindscapes’ may be relatively short for an album of this genre but it is definitely a triumphant one for The Windmill, coming six years after their ‘Tribus’ release of 2018 and shows this fine Norwegian outfit have much to offer still. I heartily recommend this for its versatile musicianship and its complex layers and soundscapes, it’s a very enjoyable listen indeed.

Released 1st July, 2024.

Order from bandcamp here:

https://thewindmillnorway.bandcamp.com/album/mindscapes

John Wenlock-Smith’s review of the 2024 musical year

2024 has been quite a year hasn’t it really? From the vagaries of politics and re-emergence of Donald Trump to again become US President again, the implosion of the Tory party and the triumphant Labour landslide, to the downfall of Assad in Syria, it has all been quite eventful, all in all.

Thankfully, musically it has been a good year, especially for the likes of Taylor Swift, whose ‘Era’ tour was a huge success, the reunion dates for Oasis were another success, especially for it’s promoters, if less so for their fans who struggled to get any reasonably priced tickets. Prog thankfully doesn’t suffer in the same way and great music shows could be easily found for very reasonable prices, except maybe David Gilmour tickets, but Steve Hackett and Big Big Train shows were far more fairly priced, as their sell out statuses clearly showed.

The year has some truly fine and many very worthwhile releases and here is what really hit it off for me. As with previous years, I have a vocal winner and an instrumental winner of the year and you’ll understand why as I reveal them to you all.

There’s also a note about why each was selected as being so very good, invariably i’ll miss something that I should have included, such is often the case as its not always easy to recall timings and release dates etc., There are no live albums or ‘best of’ though, even though several of each were very good releases.

Here we go then..

20. Wedingoth ‘Five stars (A) live’

A somewhat interesting mix of heavy metal with distinct Pink Floyd overtones, all recorded live and portraying their 2023 five star album.

19. PsychoYogi‘Astro Therapy Brain repair’

The 2024 quirky release from Chris Ramsing and band with more King Crimson styled jazz musings.

18. Nataraja‘Spirit At Play’

A one off project from Jack Jennings with Andy Edwards and John Jowitt of Frost/IQ mixing Indian classical music with synthesisers and fiery guitar a la John McLaughlin and Jimi Hendrix. A very intense listen but wonderfully conceived and delivered.

17. Infringement‘Black Science and White Lies’

More musings on the state of the world from the Norwegian stalwarts, full of dynamic music and strong observational lyrics.

16. Storm Deva‘Storm Deva’

Technically released at the back end of 2023 but gained popularity this year. Wonderful orchestral type music with fabulous vocalist/keyboardist Carollyn Eden along with sublime guitar work from Stuart Clark, some beautifully symphonic music and melodies.

15. Rick Wakeman‘Yessonata’

A totally solo piano album from the ex-Yes keyboard man which distils over thirty melodies from the prime era of Yes music. Have fun spotting the various melodies employed herein and, as a bonus, there is an instrumental synopsis of Rick’s ‘King Arthur’ piano suite.

14. Catalyst*R‘Pace Of Change’

A second album of impressive prog and electronic music from the ex Winter Machine men, check out the utterly epic Pendle Hill 1612.

13. Orion‘The Light Bringers’

The superb second full release from musical prodigy Ben Jones with lots of Rush overtones, especially with the spectacular artwork from Hugh Syme .

12. Kite Parade‘Disparity’

An album that highlights the challenges of this modern world most eloquently, there is some truly some great music on offer here.

11. The Windmill‘Mindscapes’

Latest release from the Norwegian retro-proggers. Just four tracks but such great tracks they are! One wonderfully long epic and the the other three being shorter, but no less impressive, pieces.

10. Age of Distraction‘A Game Of Whispers’

This offshoot group saw some of progressive music’s current stars (ex-This Winter Machine member John Cook, Ghost Of The Machine‘s Charlie Bramald and Mark Gatland of Hats Off Gentleman It’s Adequate to name three) band together in a new ad-hoc Project which married their progressive tendencies coupl with a harder edged sound to a fantastic impact. A second album is due in 2025 and possibly some live shows too!

9. Oddleaf‘Where Ideal And Denial Collide’

Surprisingly endearing and engrossing 70’s influenced Prog from new French outfit featuring the lovely Carina Taurer and colleagues.

8. Brendan Perkins‘Favourite Places’

A fantastic album that would most probably be of interest to Big Big Train ‘Passengers’ as the music is very expansive with very Pastoral overtones at various points. A most engrossing listen.

7. Nick Magnus‘A Strange Inheritance’

An excellent nautically themed collection of songs. This one really resonated with me and I really love Nick’s compositions on this album.

6. John Holden‘Proximity and Chance’

Another excellent release from the Cheshire based multi instrumentalist who, again, has enlisted some A-list players to support his epic pieces. This was, for several months, my album of the year but was then overshadowed by the following releases.

5. Kyros‘Mannequin’

Another top notch release and a fantastic fusion of 80’s style synth-pop and progressive music. An exquisitely produced and delivered album of sheer class.

4. Stuckfish ‘IV’

This is a major step up from this north-east quintet and is full of great songs, some of which are crying out for more live performances. Sheer class and fine quality to boot.

3. Ruby Dawn‘Blood On Water’

The superb second release from Carola Baer and colleagues, who have crafted an album that is partly based on Romeo and Juliet but also contemplates life and all it’s seasons and challenges.

2. Forgotten Gods ‘Memories’

This album came from nowhere but such is its emotional depth and rawness, along with its honesty and strong lyrics, it really makes a deep and lasting impression.

1st equal…

Instrumental album – Nick Fletcher‘A Longing For Home’

A further ten slices of Nick’s incredibly imaginative and polished musical musings with a truly impressive European based set of musicians. An album full of powerful themes and melodies along with jaw dropping skill and improvisation.

Vocal Album – John Wilkinson‘Imposter Syndrome’

Highly impressive solo album from The Swan Chorus and Ellesmere vocalist in which, over eight strong tracks, John sings of how he feels a fraud as a singer but goes on to prove that he is no fraud or imposter, rather he is a genuinely talented writer and performer. This album is a remarkable achievement and is a thing of beauty, crowned by John’s warm and evocative vocals.

It has been a vintage year for releases, you’ll notice that I’ve shied away from major label albums, despite there been several great ones but it us these 20 Albums have impacted me the most through 2024.