Review – Infringement – Black Science and White Lies – by John Wenlock-Smith

‘Black Science and White Lies’ is the third album from Infringement after ‘Alienism’ (2019) and ‘Transition’ (2017) The album follows a man’s journey through faith, his identity and, eventually, his redemption.

Infringement are Stig André Clason (guitar), Kristoffer Utby (drums), and Hans Andreas Brandal (vocals). Keyboardist Bård Thorstensen joined the band for their live performances and soon became a permanent member. Their latest addition, to complete the permanent line-up, is Emil Olsen on bass. Brandal has a somewhat theatrical style of singing that works well on this fine two track (in multiple parts) album of two pieces, White Lies and Black Science.

Together these two tracks comprise the entire 43-minute duration of the album, an unusual and somewhat intense sounding album that mixes narrative and some fiercely strident and hard-hitting music. I recommend that you have the CD booklet at hand so you can follow the narrative more easily, as it is can be a bit obscure otherwise. Even so, it’s not easy to follow what’s going on. I found it better to just go with the flow and listen to it as a complete piece of a journey. On White Lies, the acoustic guitar, keyboards and piano work very well ,acting as a counterpoint to the despair of the vocals, as does the guitar break at the end of the track that gives such great dynamics to the piece.

I actually find strong connections in this piece to the parable of the prodigal son, where a son leaves home and eventually realises he was better off at home. This theme is especially apparent White Lies pt. 3 – Apostasy which is backed with a very muscular beat and a thrust of energy and power. There is great use of the Hammond organ throughout this section with some sinewy snaking guitar lines and power chords giving the track its impetus and drive. The following section sees the return to the fold as it were as he seeks reconnection to his family. Again this is all very much theatrical in tone and actually works well like that.

After this we move to the second, five piece, suite of Black Science, which is slightly longer in length. This piece opens with good interplay between the organ and the rhythm section with powerful drums from Kristoffer Utby and strong parts from bassist Emil Olsen alongside Stig André Clason‘s subtle guitar playing. The sound is complex and constantly changing in both style and tempo, there is more than a whiff of both Gentle Giant and King Crimson in this track as it evolves steadily, the piano from Bård Thorstensen is really fine and offers a good balance to the intensity of the other sections of the track.

I will admit to not having a clue as to what this track is about, although it seems to be about a state of evolution. The organ is very prevalent during the Crimson Skies segment of the track as are the epic tones of Redemption, along with more fine guitar work from Stig André Clason, whose playing is never less than stellar, his last solo concluding the track and album in style.

‘Black Science and White Lies’ is a very interesting and somewhat intense listen, as it will demand much concentration in order to fully grasp the concepts it contains. It is worth the effort though as Infringement reward you with some excellent musical passages and performances with some great sections and playing. I really wouldn’t mind delving further into previous albums from the band to get a grip of what they are  all about.

The booklet for the album gives a lot more information and is a recommended aid to getting the best from the music of the album.

Released 19th September, 2024.

Order from bandcamp here:

https://infringement.bandcamp.com/album/black-science-and-white-lies

John Wenlock-Smith’s review of the 2024 musical year

2024 has been quite a year hasn’t it really? From the vagaries of politics and re-emergence of Donald Trump to again become US President again, the implosion of the Tory party and the triumphant Labour landslide, to the downfall of Assad in Syria, it has all been quite eventful, all in all.

Thankfully, musically it has been a good year, especially for the likes of Taylor Swift, whose ‘Era’ tour was a huge success, the reunion dates for Oasis were another success, especially for it’s promoters, if less so for their fans who struggled to get any reasonably priced tickets. Prog thankfully doesn’t suffer in the same way and great music shows could be easily found for very reasonable prices, except maybe David Gilmour tickets, but Steve Hackett and Big Big Train shows were far more fairly priced, as their sell out statuses clearly showed.

The year has some truly fine and many very worthwhile releases and here is what really hit it off for me. As with previous years, I have a vocal winner and an instrumental winner of the year and you’ll understand why as I reveal them to you all.

There’s also a note about why each was selected as being so very good, invariably i’ll miss something that I should have included, such is often the case as its not always easy to recall timings and release dates etc., There are no live albums or ‘best of’ though, even though several of each were very good releases.

Here we go then..

20. Wedingoth ‘Five stars (A) live’

A somewhat interesting mix of heavy metal with distinct Pink Floyd overtones, all recorded live and portraying their 2023 five star album.

19. PsychoYogi‘Astro Therapy Brain repair’

The 2024 quirky release from Chris Ramsing and band with more King Crimson styled jazz musings.

18. Nataraja‘Spirit At Play’

A one off project from Jack Jennings with Andy Edwards and John Jowitt of Frost/IQ mixing Indian classical music with synthesisers and fiery guitar a la John McLaughlin and Jimi Hendrix. A very intense listen but wonderfully conceived and delivered.

17. Infringement‘Black Science and White Lies’

More musings on the state of the world from the Norwegian stalwarts, full of dynamic music and strong observational lyrics.

16. Storm Deva‘Storm Deva’

Technically released at the back end of 2023 but gained popularity this year. Wonderful orchestral type music with fabulous vocalist/keyboardist Carollyn Eden along with sublime guitar work from Stuart Clark, some beautifully symphonic music and melodies.

15. Rick Wakeman‘Yessonata’

A totally solo piano album from the ex-Yes keyboard man which distils over thirty melodies from the prime era of Yes music. Have fun spotting the various melodies employed herein and, as a bonus, there is an instrumental synopsis of Rick’s ‘King Arthur’ piano suite.

14. Catalyst*R‘Pace Of Change’

A second album of impressive prog and electronic music from the ex Winter Machine men, check out the utterly epic Pendle Hill 1612.

13. Orion‘The Light Bringers’

The superb second full release from musical prodigy Ben Jones with lots of Rush overtones, especially with the spectacular artwork from Hugh Syme .

12. Kite Parade‘Disparity’

An album that highlights the challenges of this modern world most eloquently, there is some truly some great music on offer here.

11. The Windmill‘Mindscapes’

Latest release from the Norwegian retro-proggers. Just four tracks but such great tracks they are! One wonderfully long epic and the the other three being shorter, but no less impressive, pieces.

10. Age of Distraction‘A Game Of Whispers’

This offshoot group saw some of progressive music’s current stars (ex-This Winter Machine member John Cook, Ghost Of The Machine‘s Charlie Bramald and Mark Gatland of Hats Off Gentleman It’s Adequate to name three) band together in a new ad-hoc Project which married their progressive tendencies coupl with a harder edged sound to a fantastic impact. A second album is due in 2025 and possibly some live shows too!

9. Oddleaf‘Where Ideal And Denial Collide’

Surprisingly endearing and engrossing 70’s influenced Prog from new French outfit featuring the lovely Carina Taurer and colleagues.

8. Brendan Perkins‘Favourite Places’

A fantastic album that would most probably be of interest to Big Big Train ‘Passengers’ as the music is very expansive with very Pastoral overtones at various points. A most engrossing listen.

7. Nick Magnus‘A Strange Inheritance’

An excellent nautically themed collection of songs. This one really resonated with me and I really love Nick’s compositions on this album.

6. John Holden‘Proximity and Chance’

Another excellent release from the Cheshire based multi instrumentalist who, again, has enlisted some A-list players to support his epic pieces. This was, for several months, my album of the year but was then overshadowed by the following releases.

5. Kyros‘Mannequin’

Another top notch release and a fantastic fusion of 80’s style synth-pop and progressive music. An exquisitely produced and delivered album of sheer class.

4. Stuckfish ‘IV’

This is a major step up from this north-east quintet and is full of great songs, some of which are crying out for more live performances. Sheer class and fine quality to boot.

3. Ruby Dawn‘Blood On Water’

The superb second release from Carola Baer and colleagues, who have crafted an album that is partly based on Romeo and Juliet but also contemplates life and all it’s seasons and challenges.

2. Forgotten Gods ‘Memories’

This album came from nowhere but such is its emotional depth and rawness, along with its honesty and strong lyrics, it really makes a deep and lasting impression.

1st equal…

Instrumental album – Nick Fletcher‘A Longing For Home’

A further ten slices of Nick’s incredibly imaginative and polished musical musings with a truly impressive European based set of musicians. An album full of powerful themes and melodies along with jaw dropping skill and improvisation.

Vocal Album – John Wilkinson‘Imposter Syndrome’

Highly impressive solo album from The Swan Chorus and Ellesmere vocalist in which, over eight strong tracks, John sings of how he feels a fraud as a singer but goes on to prove that he is no fraud or imposter, rather he is a genuinely talented writer and performer. This album is a remarkable achievement and is a thing of beauty, crowned by John’s warm and evocative vocals.

It has been a vintage year for releases, you’ll notice that I’ve shied away from major label albums, despite there been several great ones but it us these 20 Albums have impacted me the most through 2024.